avoir besoin de

TomC1 Kwiziq Q&A super contributor

avoir besoin de

The lesson states:

To express to need + [noun], you will use :avoir besoin de/d' + (article) + noun

The examples cited show the use of the indefinite article but none include the definite article and it could be implied that the definite article is never used after  avoir besoin de/d' which is obviously wrong. It is the old problem of the specific vs the general. Since this is a perrenial problem for French learners, it might be an idea to spell it out more explictly in the lesson.

Tom

Asked 5 years ago
EmilyA2Kwiziq community member

Hi Tom! I have the same question. Can you explain when an article is not needed? 

TomC1 Kwiziq Q&A super contributor

Hi Emily,

All I was getting at was that the lesson did not give any examples using the definite article. e.g.

J'ai besoin d'un crayon  - I need a pencil (any pencil)

J'ai besoin du crayon que tu m'as prêté, hier - I need the pencil (specific) you lent me yesterday.

J'ai besoin de soutien - I need support (general)

J'ai besoin du soutien du gouvernement - I need government support (specific)

Hope this helps,

Tom

avoir besoin de

The lesson states:

To express to need + [noun], you will use :avoir besoin de/d' + (article) + noun

The examples cited show the use of the indefinite article but none include the definite article and it could be implied that the definite article is never used after  avoir besoin de/d' which is obviously wrong. It is the old problem of the specific vs the general. Since this is a perrenial problem for French learners, it might be an idea to spell it out more explictly in the lesson.

Tom

Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

Ask a question

Find your French level for FREE

Test your French to the CEFR standard

Find your French level
Getting that for you now...