Can one say, "Daniel habite à l'extérieur de la ville" to say "Daniel lives outside of the city", or is it wrong or odd? Also, when I was in school, we were told to use "au-dehors de" but you do not include it in the prepositions lesson. Do people use this preposition? It is in the Collins dictionary.
Use of à l'extérieur de and en dehors de; aussi au-dehors de (which is not mentioned)
- « Back to Q&A Forum
- « Previous questionNext question »
LeslieKwiziq community member
Use of à l'extérieur de and en dehors de; aussi au-dehors de (which is not mentioned)
This question relates to:French lesson "À côté de, en face de, à l'extérieur de, à l'intérieur de, près de, loin de, au coin de (French Prepositions)"
Asked 3 years ago
Jim Kwiziq Q&A super contributor
It is a question of "how far from".
If we want to express "outside of the city" for example, then to communicate the scale of distance involved we need another description. Peripherique, banlieue, environs.
One could use "l'extérieur de" but this does not give a sense of scale without further information.
Dehors -- en plein air, but again insufficient information without further context.
It is not "odd" nor "wrong" to use your text -- but lacking context without further information.
Leslie asked:View original
Use of à l'extérieur de and en dehors de; aussi au-dehors de (which is not mentioned)
Can one say, "Daniel habite à l'extérieur de la ville" to say "Daniel lives outside of the city", or is it wrong or odd? Also, when I was in school, we were told to use "au-dehors de" but you do not include it in the prepositions lesson. Do people use this preposition? It is in the Collins dictionary.
Don't have an account yet? Join today
Ask a question
Find your French level for FREE
Test your French to the CEFR standard
Find your French level